Wednesday, December 8, 2021

The Vienna talks don’t guarantee that all would be well for Iran

 By Aditya Vashisht

The nuclear talks at Vienna between the USA and Iran conducted through European intermediaries are going to begin next week. The talks, suspended from late June are important for Iran, which seeks to free itself from the yoke of US sanctions. But any deal, if reached, wouldn’t be a guarantee to set things right.

Domestically, Iran isn’t in a pleasant shape. The economic situation is worth raising concerns. American sanctions complimented with shortages caused by COVID-19 have led to some worrying figures. The Statistical Centre of Iran has placed inflation rate at 45%, while some consider the number to be higher in actual. Food prices have soared by more than 50% since last year and a significant proportion of the Iranian population is being labeled with the term ‘impoverished’. The printing of more notes due to sanction has been fueling inflation and the currency has lost considerable value.

Moreover, protests are being reported in the country. The latest were reported on the 20th of this month, which saw thousands protesting at the drying of a river in Eshfahan province. It was obvious that the fury was being vented at the government’s inaction. Water problem was also an issue in the July protests in Khuzestan province, which were also accompanied by the death of two people. The protests of 2019-2020 can hardly been forgotten. Three years mired in protests are apt to show that all isn’t well within Iran and that the picture isn’t good.

Oil is the commodity which carries a considerable share of Iran’s economy. Oil production, which was in millions before the famous decision of Donald Trump, has slumped to figures of a few hundred thousand. The main importer has been China, and Iran has managed to generate some billions, though in a clandestine manner. The Chinese are also complying with the US sanctions, with Iranian ships being prohibited to reach Chinese ports and Beijing using the UAE as a transit point for its goods bound for Iran.

It must be mentioned that oil isn’t a sustainable source, especially when one considers the changes in energy sector in the wake of the increasing threat of climate change. Iran is a nation which hasn’t stated its net-zero target, but this uncertainty cannot be sustained for long. Iranian energy sector’s make up would have to be changed so that it catches on with the current trends and that the share of renewables is increased. It is considered that almost a quarter of the country’s territory is suitable for the generation of solar energy. But for growing the renewable sector, which currently makes up 7% of the total energy output, investments are needed. It may sound simple, but a look at Iran’s foreign policy shows that all isn’t colourful and rosy.

 Iran’s foreign ambitions are powered by the backing of certain groups, like Hezbollah, which are designated terrorist organizations and this marks that a compromise at Vienna isn’t going to be an antidote for Tehran’s troubles. It still features on the FATF black-list. Its roles in Lebanon, Iraq, Syria and Yemen, have been important in maintaining its presence, but these are still sticking thorns which shall give the Middle East no peace. Its foreign policy is based on arms instead of constructive money, and this road cannot be travelled upon far.

To counter Western backed measures against it, Tehran has adopted the policy of looking eastwards. But here too, it would be cautious since success isn’t guaranteed. China might have signed a 25 year deal for cooperation and has made it a part of its BRI initiative, but Beijing has its paws all over the world and it means that it wouldn’t be a strong backer. China hasn’t entangled itself in any of the Middle-Eastern conflicts. It mostly deals the same with Saudis or the Israelis as with the Iranians. Also it must be mentioned that the influx of cheap Chinese goods haven’t been a pleasant sign for Iran’s small businessmen. Deepening trade relations would put it on a backfoot, and would hamper its capacity for self sufficiency, which is vital for maintaining itself.

With Russia too, there aren’t any signs of positive outcome. Engaging with Moscow means inviting isolation and further tensions, since the United States would not want Iran to act under Russian influence. The Russians have already seemed to woo, not without success, Afghanistan which adds to the Central Asian nations already courted successfully by it. Iran’s addition would strengthen Russian presence in the region. Iran’s relationship with Russia seems to have more words, since trade relations between the two aren’t at a figure which might spell strong friendship. To deepen ties in other spheres shall not be much fruitful when one takes in the whole picture.

To forget Israel would be a crucial mistake. The Jewish nation hasn’t received with favour the US attempts to achieve any settlement with Iran. Israel leaves no chance to paint Iran’s nuclear ambitions as dangerous and lacking any noble intent. Its shadow war with Tehran is well known and it hasn’t shown lately any signs of abating soon.    

Iran, therefore, seems to be in a complex position. It wants that its foreign policy objectives carry on smoothly but at the same time, it needs that it isn’t subjected to painful sanctions which eventually make its people the sufferers. The talks at Vienna have laid bare the fact that Iran needs a change, but it is upto its leaders to decide the manner in which it shall be achieved. Meanwhile, the resumed negotiations show some positive signs, but they don’t assure to put a full stop on Iran’s troubles.        

(Author is student and blogger based in Lucknow. The views expressed are personal opinion of the author. He can be reached at

Leave a Reply

Stay Connected

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest Articles